Property Management Best Practices
Renewal Lease vs. New Lease: Which Option Is Best for Your Property
Zac Maurais
March 19, 2025
Ensure utilities are set up on time.
Make easy revenue.
Make easy revenue.
Contact@UtilityProfit.com
512-XXX-XXXX
Deciding between a renewal lease and a new lease can significantly impact your property management strategy. Here's a quick breakdown to help you choose:
| Aspect | Renewal Lease | New Lease |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement Type | New contract with updated terms | Fresh agreement with a new tenant |
| Costs | Lower (~$250–$500) | Higher ($1,000–$5,000) |
| Income Stability | Predictable | Potential gaps during transitions |
| Rent Adjustments | Limited | Greater flexibility |
| Tenant Quality | Known tenant performance | Opportunity to screen for reliability |
Renewal leases are ideal for retaining good tenants and minimizing costs, while new leases can help maximize rental income and reposition properties. Start renewal discussions 90 days before lease expiration to make informed decisions.
Understanding the difference between renewal and new leases is key for property managers looking to make smart decisions about their rentals. Here’s a breakdown of what each type involves and the factors to keep in mind.
A renewal lease extends the agreement with an existing tenant, often updating terms like the lease duration, notice period (usually 60–90 days), rent, or policies[1]. A new lease, on the other hand, starts a fresh rental agreement with a different tenant, requiring steps like tenant screening, move-in preparation, and setting up payments[3].
Renewals often come with less hassle since the tenant’s payment history and reliability are already known. But deciding between the two depends on several considerations:
Choosing between a renewal and a new lease can impact your property management strategy. Renewals offer continuity and fewer administrative tasks, while new leases allow for updated terms and potentially higher rents.
Renewal leases simplify property management and help build better relationships with tenants.
Cost Savings
Renewal leases help cut down on turnover costs. On average, property managers save about $2,500 in expenses like marketing, which can range from $50 to several hundred dollars [5]. They also minimize the typical 30–45-day vacancy period, ensuring steady rental income [5].
Flexible Rent Adjustments
Renewal leases allow landlords to adjust rent in different ways, depending on their strategy:
| Adjustment Type | Description | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed Percentage | Annual increase at a set rate | 2-5% per year [6] |
| CPI-Based | Adjusted based on inflation | Varies with economic indicators [6] |
| Market-Based | Reflects current local market rates | Based on local market conditions [6] |
Shorter Lease Terms
Leasing terms are becoming more flexible, with shorter renewal periods gaining popularity. As Sam Caulton, CFO of Re-Leased, explains:
"Landlords are now managing their leasing relationships with customer service at the forefront - to ensure leases are renewed. The focus on customer service and tenant satisfaction becomes paramount as the office market moves away from traditional long-term leases." [8]
Better Tenant Relationships
A well-organized renewal lease can improve landlord-tenant interactions by focusing on:
These measures make tenants feel valued while also simplifying administrative tasks for landlords.
Administrative Ease
Renewal leases reduce the workload for property managers by cutting down on paperwork. Using property management software to standardize renewal processes further boosts efficiency [10].
Interestingly, about 60% of tenants opt to renew their leases [9].
New leases give property managers the chance to update terms, attract tenants that align with their goals, and adjust pricing to match current market trends. This approach also helps refine tenant requirements and set competitive rental rates.
Tenant Screening Essentials
Screening potential tenants is crucial for finding reliable renters. Here’s a breakdown of the process and costs involved:
| Screening Component | Cost Range | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Credit Check | $15–$40 | Assess financial responsibility |
| Criminal Background | $15–$40 | Promote safety and legal compliance |
| Eviction History | $5–$20 | Check rental history |
| Complete Package | $35–$75 | Comprehensive review [13] |
Leveraging Market-Rate Pricing
New leases allow property managers to take advantage of current market conditions. Recent statistics highlight the financial benefits:
This demonstrates the potential for higher returns by focusing on new lease agreements.
Financial Guidelines for Tenants
Prospective tenants are typically required to meet specific financial benchmarks, including:
These standards help ensure tenants are financially stable and reduce the risk of missed payments.
Initial Setup Costs
Turning over a unit comes with upfront expenses, but these are often outweighed by future returns. On average, turnover costs range from $1,000 to $5,000 [9] and cover essentials like repairs, marketing, administrative tasks, and screening fees, all of which must align with local regulations.
Regulatory Compliance
Creating new leases requires careful attention to legal requirements, including:
Automated screening tools can help property managers ensure consistency and compliance throughout the process.
When deciding between renewal and new leases, consider how each option impacts operations, finances, and tenant quality.
Renewing a lease with an existing tenant can save property managers up to $1,000 in turnover costs [15]. This approach minimizes disruptions, ensures steady income, and keeps operations running smoothly without the challenges that come with tenant turnover.
While new leases come with higher upfront costs, they offer opportunities to reposition properties. Vacancy turnover expenses can range between $1,000 and $5,000 [9], but these costs can be offset by adjusting rents to current market rates and making meaningful property upgrades.
Here's a quick comparison of renewal and new leases:
| Aspect | Renewal Lease | New Lease |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Costs | Lower fees (~$250–$500 [15]) | Higher turnover costs ($1,000–$5,000 [9]) |
| Income Stability | Predictable income | Potential income gaps during transitions |
| Tenant Quality | Known performance, less uncertainty | Opportunity to screen for reliable tenants |
| Rental Rate Flexibility | Limited adjustments due to existing agreements | Greater potential to match market rates |
| Property Updates | Minor updates typically required | Allows for major renovations |
From a financial perspective, renewals offer a stable income with minimal turnover expenses. On the other hand, new leases can align rental rates with market trends and allow for property improvements, potentially increasing the property's overall value.
Each option comes with its own risks. Renewals may mean keeping unreliable tenants or being limited in rent changes. New leases, however, carry risks like longer vacancy periods, uncertain tenant reliability, and higher turnover expenses.
Ultimately, the decision between renewing or signing a new lease depends on your property’s needs, the current market, and your long-term goals.
Deciding on the best lease option for your property involves weighing several factors. Here’s a breakdown of when each lease type might be the better fit.
A renewal lease is ideal when tenants have a solid track record of paying on time and maintaining the property. Renewing a lease can help you avoid turnover costs, which can reach up to $1,000 [15].
"The #1 mistake that landlords and managers make with lease renewals is that they set up a new lease." - Hemlane [16]
To make the process smooth:
If these conditions aren’t met, it may be time to explore a new lease.
A new lease makes sense when dealing with issues like late payments, outdated property conditions, below-market rent, or tenant-related problems. While turnover costs can range from $1,000 to $5,000 [9], the long-term benefits - like better cash flow and improved property management - can outweigh these expenses.
| Scenario | Action Required | Expected Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Poor Payment History | Screen new tenants thoroughly | More reliable cash flow |
| Property Needs Updates | Plan renovations between tenants | Boosted property value |
| Below-Market Rent | Adjust rates to match the market | Increased rental income |
| Tenant Issues | Replace troublesome tenants | Smoother property management |
To make the right choice, consider tenant history, the property’s condition, and local market trends. Evaluate these key areas:
See how Utility Profit works in 1 minute
